DimWit Politics

The Kaepernick Curse

 Breaking News
  • Are Liberals Causing WildFires? The massive outbreak of raging wildfires in California drew a series of eye-opening tweets from President Trump criticizing state officials about their environmental regulations and water management policies. Experts have...
  • Campaign Finance Laws Need To Be Repealed… For the Most Part Our most recent election cycle had one characteristic like so many before it: The political left again called for campaign finance reform that would “drive money out of politics.” Oh,...
  • The Comedy of Political Comity The most common refrains in politics today are those calls for more civility. We need to respect the opinions of others. We need more tolerance. So sayeth almost everyone. Of...
  • Caravan to Sue Trump For Violating Their Rights Consider who benefits the most from illegal immigration. The first and most obvious winner is the DNC, which is happy to obtain scores of new voters. If you look at...
  • CNN’s Don Lemon Lives Up to His Name If the bosses at CNN ever wonder why their network has slowly sunk into a distant third place among the cable news programs (and 11th place for all cable programming),...

The Kaepernick Curse

The Kaepernick Curse
August 14
17:39 2018

With the kick-off of the football season, the National Football League is once again steeped in a fan-fleeing controversy over players taking a knee during the National Anthem. The NFL, under the leadership of Roger Goodell, is floundering in pursuit of an effective strategy to deal with the issue.

However, they will never find one if they continue to predicate a policy on a foundation of political correctness and identity politics. That is NOT what the controversy is all about. It is not a racial or racist issue from the standpoint of the fans who are walking away. It is an issue of patriotism and a belief in E Pluribus Unum. Those fans would be bolting if the kneelers were all white and protesting abortion, or gun control, or the legalization of marijuana. Until the league and the kneelers understand that, the misplaced protest and the mishandled response will continue – and the NFL will see ratings fall and more empty stadium seats.

Media personalities and the sycophantic panelists lay the blame for politicizing the issue on President Trump. That is prima facie nonsense. It was Colin Kaepernick who ignited the “Anthem Issue” when he maladroitly decided to conflate the legitimate issue of police violence against young black men with the overarching issue of respecting America as a whole. Trump can certainly be criticized for the nature of his response – once again being needlessly pugnacious — but he did not start this fight.

The NFL leadership thought they were clever in proposing what they considered a “reasonable compromise.” Players who wished to refrain from honoring the National Anthem could remain in the locker room until the final note had been played. The problem with that compromise is that neither the fans nor the players liked it. No matter how a player avoids respecting the National Anthem – remaining seated, kneeling or just not showing up – it has the same impact on the fans.

Players prone to protest saw the new NFL rule as a violation of their First Amendment right even though freedom of speech does not apply to the workplace. The players’ union chimed in with a charge that the new rule was a violation of the contract. Maybe so. I did not bother reading the contract.

The only solution that might have ended the prolonged controversy was for the owners to exert their right to control the workplace and require players to respectfully stand for the National Anthem or face fines, suspensions or termination. No doubt there would have been howling from the locker room. For a short time, there may have even been protestors marching in front of the stadium erroneously claiming the players’ freedom of speech was being violated. A few players may have even handed in their jerseys. But, in a relatively short time, the controversy would have passed, and the NFL could have gone back to worrying about tax breaks and long-term injury liability.

Perhaps that is still the only real solution, but now that the NFL leadership and the owners have been floundering in public for the past year, even that solution becomes more problematic.

The Kaepernick protest did nothing to win support for the cause that provoked it. The police abuse issue has been lost in the much bigger issue of national unity and patriotism. No respect for the anthem equates with no respect for the teams.

Fans do not like the recent round of kneeling any more than Kaepernick’s original one-man protest. And the NFL is no closer to finding a solution – and they will not as long as they avoid considering the only option left.

About Author

Larry Horist

Larry Horist

Larry Horist is a conservative activist with an extensive background in economics, public policy and politics. Clients of his consulting firm have included such conservative icons as Steve Forbes and Milton Friedman, as well as the White House. He has testified as an expert witness before legislative bodies, including the U. S. Congress, and lectured at major colleges and universities. An award-winning debater, his insightful and sometimes controversial commentaries appear frequently on the editorial pages of newspapers across the nation. He can be reached at lph@thomasandjoyce.com.

Related Articles

7 Comments

  1. David
    David August 15, 16:15

    The solution is take a knee after and not during the National Anthem. Players claim they are not against the National Anthem…then let them prove it and kneel afterwards.

    Reply to this comment
  2. d
    d August 15, 16:21

    Kaepernick and his un-educated, blind, followers
    may be the downfall of the entire professional football world. Then, Jerry Jones and the other owners who have profited through huge tax breaks and stadium deals born on the backs of local
    property owners, can turn their stadiums
    into venues for college and high school
    teams who play for the love of the game.

    Reply to this comment
  3. Richard Green
    Richard Green August 15, 16:30

    The players have the right to protest. However, they do not have the right to protest on “company time.” That’s the real issue that the NFL fails to address. As a small business owner, I will fire any employee that chooses to protest on company time. Pretty simple.

    Reply to this comment
  4. Brendan
    Brendan August 15, 16:30

    As long as you are considering what *might* have been done early on to limit this controversy, why don’t you mention the obvious one: the NFL should have left Kap alone to do what he chooses as an individual. As soon as they went after him, it enlarged to a question of worker and racial solidarity. No one, least of all the players, actually likes the League or the owners. Kap should have been left alone, his protest occasionally mentioned in passing as an example of Americans’ right to protest, and it all would have died down. To the extent it got continued interest, it might even have been interest focused on what you rightly name is a legitimate underlying issue: law enforcement treatment of minority persons .
    Now that opportunity is gone, and I would lay the blame much more on the owners’ and the League’s ham-handed response than on the effort of one man to call attention to the troubles his people were having. He was only one guy, but they managed to turn it into a whole union of guys. good luck with that.

    Reply to this comment
  5. Eric
    Eric August 15, 17:02

    If they kneel and disrespect the nation then fire them!

    Reply to this comment
  6. DG
    DG August 16, 00:31

    Kaepernick was pretty much a one-man protest, and had largely been pushed to the background until Trump when on his twitter rant. He is the one that is responsible for this whole issue being blown up the way it was. If he’d just shut up, it would have been over with a long time ago.

    Reply to this comment
  7. kbhret
    kbhret August 16, 23:24

    Roger Goodell has a double dose of white man’s curse..
    HE WON’T STAND UP AND FIGHT

    Reply to this comment

Write a Comment

Special Offer

Latest Comments

"Harvest-able trees" aren't the only things that need to be cut or burned before they...

There is not a harvest-able tree within 50 miles of Malibu; how do you explain...

I guess you don't know how to read. His name is Larry Horist. His name...

Take a Look!

12174 - DimWit Politics - Display - 300x250 B - [WEB].txt Displaying 12174 - DimWit Politics - Display - 300x250 B - [WEB].txt.

Don’t Miss This!

12174 - DimWit Politics - Display - 300x250 B - [WEB].txt Displaying 12174 - DimWit Politics - Display - 300x250 B - [WEB].txt.